What is Confirmationism?

S8-SA1-0447

Grade Level:

Class 7

AI/ML, Data Science, Research, Journalism, Law, any domain requiring critical thinking

Definition

What is it?

Confirmationism is when we look for information that supports what we already believe and ignore information that goes against it. It's like having a favourite cricket team and only remembering their wins, forgetting their losses.

Simple Example

Quick Example

Imagine you believe that eating samosas every day makes you smart. You then notice that your friend who eats samosas got good marks. You use this to 'confirm' your belief, even though many other friends who don't eat samosas also get good marks, and your friend might be studying hard.

Worked Example

Step-by-Step

Let's say a student, Priya, believes that studying only at night is the best way to get good marks.
---
1. Priya studies at night for her Science test and scores 85/100. She thinks, 'See, night study works!'
---
2. Later, she studies in the morning for her Math test and scores 70/100. She thinks, 'Morning study isn't good, I told you!'
---
3. She forgets that her Science test was easier, or that she spent more time on Science, or that her friend Rohan studied in the morning and scored 90/100 in Math. She only focuses on the results that 'confirm' her belief about night study.
---
4. The 'confirmationism' here is ignoring other factors and examples (like Rohan's score or test difficulty) that challenge her initial belief. Her conclusion is based on selected evidence.

Why It Matters

Understanding confirmationism helps us think more clearly and make better decisions. It's important for scientists to find true facts, for journalists to report balanced news, and for anyone doing research to avoid biased conclusions. It helps you be a fair judge in any situation.

Common Mistakes

MISTAKE: Only searching for news articles that agree with your opinion on a topic. | CORRECTION: Actively look for articles and opinions from different viewpoints, even those you disagree with, to get a full picture.

MISTAKE: Believing a rumour just because one person you trust told you, without checking facts. | CORRECTION: Always verify information, especially important news, from multiple reliable sources before believing or sharing it.

MISTAKE: Assuming a new product (like a phone or a game) is bad because your friend had one bad experience, ignoring many positive reviews. | CORRECTION: Look at a wide range of reviews and experiences, both good and bad, to form a balanced opinion.

Practice Questions

Try It Yourself

QUESTION: Your favourite actor releases a new movie, and you automatically assume it's amazing even before watching it. Is this an example of confirmationism? | ANSWER: Yes, because you are expecting it to be good based on your existing belief about the actor, potentially ignoring any flaws.

QUESTION: A student believes that all teachers give harder exams on Fridays. They remember one Friday exam that was tough. What should they do to avoid confirmationism? | ANSWER: They should check all their exam schedules and results for both Friday and non-Friday exams, and also compare the difficulty level of questions across all exams, not just remember one instance.

QUESTION: You are trying to decide if a new app is good. You read 5 positive reviews and 2 negative reviews. If you only focus on the 5 positive reviews and decide the app is great, what thinking trap are you falling into? Explain why. | ANSWER: You are falling into confirmationism. You are giving more weight to the information (positive reviews) that confirms your likely hope for the app to be good, while downplaying or ignoring the negative information.

MCQ

Quick Quiz

Which of these situations best describes confirmationism?

A student carefully studies all sides of an argument before forming an opinion.

A person only reads news articles from sources that share their political views.

A scientist tests their hypothesis by trying to prove it wrong.

A chef tries new ingredients to improve a dish, even if they've never used them before.

The Correct Answer Is:

Option B shows confirmationism because the person is seeking out only information that already aligns with their existing beliefs, rather than looking at a balanced view. Options A, C, and D show open-mindedness and critical thinking.

Real World Connection

In the Real World

In today's digital world, confirmationism is very common. When you scroll through social media feeds, algorithms often show you posts and news that match what you've liked before. This creates an 'echo chamber' where you mostly see content that confirms your existing views, making it harder to see other perspectives.

Key Vocabulary

Key Terms

BIAS: A tendency to lean in a certain direction, either for or against something | EVIDENCE: Facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid | OBJECTIVE: Not influenced by personal feelings or opinions in considering and representing facts | CRITICAL THINKING: The objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment.

What's Next

What to Learn Next

Now that you understand confirmationism, you should learn about 'Critical Thinking'. Critical thinking is the skill of evaluating information objectively and fairly, which helps you overcome biases like confirmationism and make smarter decisions in every part of your life.