Inaugurated by IN-SPACe
ISRO Registered Space Tutor
S5-SA1-0609
What is the Simon Commission (purpose)?
Grade Level:
Class 7
Law, Civic Literacy, Economics, FinTech, Geopolitics, Personal Finance, Indian Governance
Definition
What is it?
The Simon Commission was a group of seven British Members of Parliament, led by Sir John Simon, sent to British India in 1927. Its main purpose was to study constitutional reforms in India and suggest changes to the existing system of governance, especially regarding how Indians could participate more in their own administration.
Simple Example
Quick Example
Imagine your school principal forms a committee to decide new rules for the annual sports day. This committee is only made up of teachers, with no students. The Simon Commission was similar: it was a committee formed by the British government to decide India's future rules, but it had no Indian members.
Worked Example
Step-by-Step
Let's understand the purpose of the Simon Commission step-by-step:
1. **Background:** After World War I, the British government introduced the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms (1919) to give Indians limited self-governance, but many Indians felt it wasn't enough.
---
2. **Need for Review:** The British government promised to review these reforms after 10 years to see if more changes were needed.
---
3. **Formation of Commission:** In 1927, two years earlier than promised, the British government appointed the Simon Commission for this review.
---
4. **Key Purpose:** The primary goal of the Simon Commission was to assess the working of the 1919 reforms and recommend further constitutional changes for India.
---
5. **Major Flaw:** The biggest issue was that all seven members of the Commission were British, with no Indian representatives.
---
6. **Result:** This led to widespread protests and boycotts across India, as Indians felt insulted and believed their views wouldn't be truly represented.
**Answer:** The Simon Commission's purpose was to review India's constitutional progress and suggest future reforms, but its all-British composition sparked massive opposition.
Why It Matters
Understanding the Simon Commission helps us see how India fought for self-rule and shaped its own laws, which is crucial for Indian Governance. This historical event shows the importance of fair representation in Law and Civic Literacy. Learning about such commissions can even inspire future diplomats or policy advisors in Geopolitics.
Common Mistakes
MISTAKE: Thinking the Simon Commission was formed to grant India complete independence immediately. | CORRECTION: The Commission's purpose was to suggest *reforms* to the existing British rule, not to end it or grant full independence.
MISTAKE: Believing the Simon Commission was welcomed by all Indians. | CORRECTION: The Commission faced widespread boycotts and protests because it had no Indian members, which was seen as an insult to Indian self-respect.
MISTAKE: Confusing the Simon Commission with other movements like the Non-Cooperation Movement. | CORRECTION: While both were anti-British, the Simon Commission was a specific British-appointed body, and the protests against it were a reaction to its formation and composition.
Practice Questions
Try It Yourself
QUESTION: What was the main reason Indians protested against the Simon Commission? | ANSWER: Indians protested because the Simon Commission had no Indian members, making them feel their voices would not be heard.
QUESTION: When was the Simon Commission appointed, and what was its core task? | ANSWER: The Simon Commission was appointed in 1927. Its core task was to review the constitutional reforms in British India and suggest further changes.
QUESTION: If the Simon Commission had included Indian members, do you think its reception in India would have been different? Explain your reasoning. | ANSWER: Yes, its reception would likely have been very different. The main reason for the widespread boycott was the exclusion of Indians. If Indian members were included, it would have shown respect for Indian opinions and might have led to greater cooperation, even if its recommendations were still debated.
MCQ
Quick Quiz
What was the primary purpose of the Simon Commission?
To declare India's immediate independence
To review constitutional reforms in India and suggest changes
To establish a new British trading company in India
To fund new railway projects across India
The Correct Answer Is:
B
The Simon Commission's main job was to study and recommend changes to India's governance system. Options A, C, and D were not its primary objectives.
Real World Connection
In the Real World
Just like how the Indian government forms committees or commissions today (e.g., to review education policies or economic plans), the British government formed the Simon Commission. However, unlike today's commissions that typically include diverse experts and public representatives, the Simon Commission lacked Indian voices, highlighting the importance of inclusive decision-making in any modern democracy.
Key Vocabulary
Key Terms
CONSTITUTIONAL REFORMS: Changes made to the basic laws and principles by which a country is governed | GOVERNANCE: The way a country or organization is managed and controlled | BOYCOTT: Refusing to buy, use, or participate in something as a way of protesting | COMMISSION: A group of people officially given the task of finding out about something or controlling something | REPRESENTATION: The action of speaking or acting on behalf of someone or something
What's Next
What to Learn Next
Next, you should learn about the 'Lahore Session of 1929' and the demand for 'Purna Swaraj' (complete independence). This will show you how Indian leaders responded to the Simon Commission's report and intensified their struggle for freedom!
